It was alright, but in some parts, it didn't make sense. Take for instance, the scenes prior, during and after the ramming. Why couldn't Shinzon move away faster? We was zooming by the E and other Romulan ships blasting them to smithereens. All of a sudden, he couln't move.
Oh, please.
Then when they hit, we knew Picard's ship lost atmosphere, why not Shinzon's? Instead, the little Remans are running away from the saucer section. I know that hole they punched through wasn't air-tight. Blast some of those bastards through! And afterwards, the pause. The long dreaded pause. Maybe if there was some good dramatic music during the moment instead of a silent, 15 second look of the damage, I would be pleased.
It's good, but there's a lot of crap wrong with it.