Vampire The Masquerade: Bloodlines

It's using the HL2 source for its engine so the first person shooting aspect would have been solid, if it weren't for the sucky part that guns don't deal much damage to monsters as opposed to melee. Melee combat on the other hand is clunky so hand to hand combat feels like a sloppy cross between Jedi Outcast and Grand theft Auto 3.

It's a good thing combat is not the game's main focus, Plus, I can do stealth kills Sam Fisher style. Actually, now that I think more about it, It's almost like a Grand Theft Auto 3 with vampires.