I'd agree with most of this list save for Spider-man 2, which I thought was weak.
I haven't seen Sin City so I can't comment.
But there's only a limited number of comic-based films out there anyway, isn't there?
Lets see:
Catwoman
Road to Perdition
From Hell
Daredevil
Elektra
Hulk
Incredible Hulk
Ghost Rider
The Rocketeer
Mystery Men
X-men 3
Blade (and its sequels)
Steel
The Punisher (both versions)
I'm not seeing much there that should be making any sort of list, other than a shit list.
Wolverine is coming of course but I'm not envisaging much other than a gore-fest.
