|
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 25,493 Likes: 37
brutally Kamphausened 15000+ posts
|
brutally Kamphausened 15000+ posts
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 25,493 Likes: 37 |
Yeah, I prefer the "original" version of the sketch from nearly thirty years ago. Among other things, the original captures (with them just standing there) the individual personalities of the team members (regal Storm, defiant Wolverine, relaxed Banshee, solid Peter, alert Nightcrawler and leader Cyclops) much better than the grinning idiots in the new version. Used as the cover for COMIC READER 167:  There was also a nice Marvel house-ad at the time of the Claremont/Byrne X-men run, that showed the old X-men and new X-men together. A run that presented Byrne at the peak of his talent, to be sure. A beautiful house ad By Cockrum, that oddly was used to promote the Claremont/Byrne/Austin run, after Cockrum had left the series.  And odd also that Byrne never did a similar house ad for his own run. In interviews at the time Byrne similarly expressed annoyance that there were Cockrum X-Men character heads in the upper left of covers for most of his run, as if it was still Cockrum's book and Byrne was just the fill-in guest artist for 4 years from 1977-1981.
|
|
|
Entire Thread
|
John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2003-07-15 1:48 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
First Amongst Daves
|
2003-07-15 4:52 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Grimm
|
2003-07-15 5:31 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Pig Iran
|
2003-07-15 5:41 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
First Amongst Daves
|
2003-07-15 5:56 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
profh0011
|
2003-07-15 6:01 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
First Amongst Daves
|
2003-07-15 6:10 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Mr. Nobody
|
2003-07-15 7:49 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
the G-man
|
2003-07-15 12:35 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Animalman
|
2003-07-15 4:36 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Disco Steve
|
2003-07-16 7:48 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
profh0011
|
2003-07-15 10:06 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the...(AVENGERS 188, checklist 1975-1980)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2003-07-15 10:06 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the...(Profh0011,good early Byrne at Marvel)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2003-07-15 10:17 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Pig Iran
|
2003-07-15 11:05 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Im Not Mister Mxyzptlk
|
2003-07-16 1:54 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
First Amongst Daves
|
2003-07-16 2:58 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Im Not Mister Mxyzptlk
|
2003-07-16 3:11 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Pig Iran
|
2003-07-16 4:36 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
profh0011
|
2003-07-17 7:29 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
First Amongst Daves
|
2003-07-17 9:46 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Jim Jackson
|
2003-07-18 2:51 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the...(FF 232, C A 249, checklist 1980-1986)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2003-07-18 6:47 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the...(checklist 1986-1989)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2004-04-02 3:59 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Captain Cranky
|
2004-04-02 8:30 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
the G-man
|
2004-04-03 1:23 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the...(X-MEN 141, checklist 1989-1993)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2004-04-03 10:03 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Jim Jackson
|
2004-04-05 2:13 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
jafabian
|
2004-04-05 9:58 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the (last checklist, 1995-1998)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2004-04-06 1:30 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
Pig Iran
|
2004-04-06 5:37 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
the G-man
|
2004-04-06 11:52 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
Steve T
|
2004-04-07 3:33 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the(TWO IN ONE 56 cover, Ordway, etc.)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2004-07-02 3:52 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
Jim Jackson
|
2004-07-02 9:58 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
Jim Jackson
|
2004-07-07 4:40 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years...(Byrne's new JLA, Byrne's 1987 DOOM PATROL annual)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2004-07-09 6:50 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
Jim Jackson
|
2004-07-09 12:21 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
ShazamGrrl1
|
2004-07-11 7:12 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the
|
First Amongst Daves
|
2004-07-11 5:31 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the (CAPT AM 250, FF trades)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2004-09-11 3:24 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Eurostar
|
2004-04-02 8:12 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? (ROG 2000)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2006-05-08 8:24 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? (ROG 2000)
|
allan1
|
2006-05-08 10:39 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? (ROG 2000)
|
Matter-eater Man
|
2006-05-09 3:55 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? (ROG 2000 vs Howard )
|
Wonder Boy
|
2006-05-09 7:03 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Byrne fanzine )
|
Wonder Boy
|
2006-05-14 8:50 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the.. (Rog 2000, COMIC READER 128 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2006-05-21 7:04 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Irwin Schwab
|
2006-05-21 7:15 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
rufusTfirefly
|
2006-05-22 11:11 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
the G-man
|
2006-05-23 12:18 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Captain Sweden
|
2006-05-23 11:19 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
thedoctor
|
2006-05-23 11:22 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Captain Sweden
|
2006-05-23 11:23 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( Byrne X-MEN pages)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2006-05-24 7:37 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( Byrne & his sharpie)
|
Irwin Schwab
|
2006-05-24 2:01 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( Byrne & his sharpie)
|
Captain Sweden
|
2006-05-25 9:16 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( Byrne & his sharpie)
|
the G-man
|
2006-05-25 11:35 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( Byrne p & i examples)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2006-05-26 3:11 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? (Byrne's OMAC, reviews)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2006-07-16 2:34 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-09-19 5:18 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Pig Iran
|
2011-09-19 11:35 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-09-20 8:46 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-09-20 9:08 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:00 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
rex
|
2011-11-30 11:07 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:50 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:51 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:52 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:54 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:54 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:55 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:57 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:57 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:57 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:57 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:58 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:58 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:58 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:58 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:59 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 11:59 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 12:00 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 12:00 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 12:00 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 12:01 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 12:01 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 12:01 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
rex
|
2011-11-30 11:57 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
rex
|
2011-11-30 12:09 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Captain Sweden
|
2011-12-01 9:13 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Prometheus
|
2011-12-01 9:14 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Captain Sweden
|
2011-12-01 9:20 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
the G-man
|
2011-12-01 9:25 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Captain Sweden
|
2011-12-02 3:01 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-11-30 12:03 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-12-04 12:53 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Captain Sweden
|
2011-12-07 7:39 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2011-12-08 6:39 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
the G-man
|
2011-12-08 7:45 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2014-12-30 9:00 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
the G-man
|
2019-04-06 4:57 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2019-04-07 12:04 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2019-04-17 9:44 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
the G-man
|
2019-05-01 3:36 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2019-05-02 2:15 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2019-05-02 2:33 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2020-04-10 3:43 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2014-12-30 9:48 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2014-12-30 10:07 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2019-04-04 10:34 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2018-09-08 8:47 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2019-03-12 7:51 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2019-03-19 7:51 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2019-03-25 11:18 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2007-01-06 7:17 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
allan1
|
2007-01-06 2:04 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Pig Iran
|
2007-01-06 4:34 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
John Byrne
|
2007-01-06 5:12 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
allan1
|
2007-01-07 12:11 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
John Byrne
|
2007-01-06 5:13 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
DavidBowieMoo!
|
2007-06-04 11:17 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
PJP
|
2007-06-02 7:30 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
notwedge
|
2007-06-03 11:51 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
allan1
|
2007-06-04 3:12 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
DavidBowieMoo!
|
2007-06-04 11:16 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2023-08-29 6:41 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2023-09-08 5:45 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2023-09-08 5:55 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2023-09-08 6:03 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2023-09-08 6:29 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2023-09-08 6:50 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2023-09-08 6:59 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2024-02-14 12:06 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong? ( early Rog 2000 cover)
|
Wonder Boy
|
2024-05-27 7:41 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
First Amongst Daves
|
2024-06-04 9:08 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2024-05-27 7:42 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2024-05-27 9:37 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2024-05-28 1:30 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Son of Mxy
|
2024-06-05 2:46 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2024-06-07 4:30 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2024-06-07 4:41 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2025-01-27 11:50 AM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2025-01-27 3:15 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2025-01-27 3:33 PM
|
Re: John Byrne: The good years, the bad years, and what the heck went wrong?
|
Wonder Boy
|
2025-01-27 3:50 PM
|
|
|
|