Quote: Jim Jackson said: I'm not a Consitiution scholar. I can't answer whether or not the student's response is a *scholarly* work. You need another Constitution scholar to evaluate the work to see if it's a scholarly response.
No you don't, actually, since the essay has very little to do with the Constitution itself. Simply read the question asked, then try to find a response to the question within the essay.
Good luck.
Quote: Jim Jackson said: And what year of college is this guy in?
That really shouldn't matter and for this essay I don't think it does. For the sake of argument, let's CONSERVATIVELY assume this student is in his very first semester in college (which, I'm quite sure he isn't).
Quote: Jim Jackson said: What grade did this response get?
