Based on JLA's modship of the Wimmins' forum, I vote Mr JLA, because I think he'd bring the same enthusiastic contribution to this forum that he does to that one.
And PJP, because he clearly wants the job, and makes reading these boards so much fun.
I'd vote Nowhereman for the same reason, but I'm not sure he wants the job.
So my third choice would be Animalman, who is knowledgeable and also a large contributor to the forum.
