Originally Posted By: Nowhereman
Thats neither here nor there, you said he was a crap actor and had only made poor films.


and others said the same about berry / holmes / jolie. its all speculation, and, really, its difficult to say how well someone will do in a situation.

my argument is, that the creators of the movies have been so good, they can take most anyone and get the best out of them.


 Originally Posted By: Nowhereman

Jolie, has yet to do anything that she has had any real aclaim for.
Even her serious roles such as Gia, have hardly met with huge praise for her acting abilities.


you mean aside from her oscar?

or emmy? or golden globes? (both kinds!)

 Originally Posted By: Nowhereman

Did Catwoman fail because of Berry, or did it fail because the film (and especially the story) was shit!


i never saw it. cuz i thought it looked terrible. but from what little i did see in trailers and such, it seems like the direction of the movie was awful, not (necessarily just) hale berry.

giant picture